ABOUT THE AUTHOR: Leon Harris TEP is an Israeli
certified public accountant and a UK chartered accountant at Harris
Consulting & Tax Ltd in Israel
The Israeli Tax Authority (ITA) launched a new temporary
voluntary disclosure procedure (VDP) on 15 November. Israeli
residents have until 30 June 2012 to report previously undisclosed
income on foreign (non-Israeli) assets. This action will confer
immunity from criminal proceedings, and some relief regarding
fines, interest and indexation. This is an improvement over the
older fixed Israeli VDP dating back to 10 April 2005, which will
partly apply until 30 June 2012 and will fully apply again after
that date.
According to the ITA, cases where the temporary VDP will apply
include:
- unreported income from foreign assets received by inheritance
or gift from a foreign resident
- unreported income from foreign assets acquired with money
derived from income generated in Israel or abroad on which tax was
paid or no tax was due in Israel; and
- unreported income from foreign assets on which the liability to
tax arose since the 2003 tax year, following the Israeli tax reform
of 2003, which made Israeli residents taxable on worldwide income
instead of Israeli-source income.
The temporary procedure does not apply to assets and income
derived from a ‘crime’ under the Penal Law (defined in s24
as an offence carrying a punishment of more than three years), or
for applications made following or in parallel to an investigation
or examination by a State authority, according to the older fixed
VDP.
The panel of tax officials led by the ITA legal advisor will
review applications for the temporary VDP, but it won’t deal with
those that do not meet the criteria. Nevertheless, according to the
ITA Circular, ‘no use will be made in the criminal and civil arena
with the information included in the application’.
‘The tax according to the assessment will not bear
interest or fines’
Applications meeting the criteria will be confirmed by the panel
and the applicant will be given immunity from criminal sanctions
under the tax laws within the ambit of the ITA. And the panel will
issue a civil tax assessment, which may be by agreement with the
applicant. The tax according to the assessment will not bear
interest or fines. Additionally, the panel may grant relief
regarding indexation (for inflation) of the tax, and may even
cancel the indexation.
In conclusion, the temporary VDP is worth considering in
applicable cases if an Israeli resident has a tax skeleton in the
closet. The procedure not only offers immunity from criminal
sanctions, but also immunity from interest and penalties. Any such
application should be made by 30 June 2012 after checking things
out.
Key considerations
- It is unclear whether anonymous applications can initially be
filed.
- Presumably, as this will be a civil procedure, the panel’s
conclusions will not be published.
- Difficulty may arise in cases involving unreported income used
to buy assets in Israel rather than abroad.
- If a case does not meet the criteria because an investigation
or an examination is under way, will the Israeli Tax Authority be
precluded from using information included in the voluntary
disclosure procedure (VDP) application? It appears so.
- Restricting the temporary VDP to Israeli-resident applicants
will cause problems, in particular for trustees of trusts that are
taxable in Israel, e.g. if the settlor is or was an Israeli
resident. The 2006 tax regime deems the trustee ‘assessable and
chargeable to tax’ unless the trustee and the settlor, beneficiary
or beneficiaries agree otherwise. Is this discriminatory under
Israel’s tax treaties with 50 other countries? It could be under
treaties with the US and Canada, but most others don’t yet address
trusts, resulting in uncertainty. Specialist Israeli advice should
be sought.